Meteorite Impacts in Space and Time
Geol 117

Group Project #8


 

Melissa Threadgill, Anna Eisenberg

Can life be transported between planets (or even solar systems) by impacts ("panspermia")?

May 11, 2001

Abstract

Panspermia is a topic that has provoked much controversy throughout the years and has become important recently with the possible discovery of fossilized bacteria on a Martian meteorite. While there are many different proposed versions of panspermia, the most feasible is that of lithopanspermia, or the transport of life via meteorites or comets. There are many hurdles microbial life on a meteorite must go through in order to colonize another planet: getting off the planet without dying, surviving the length of time it takes to reach a new planet, surviving the harsh conditions of deep space (including freezing cold and UV rays) and then landing on the new planet unharmed and proceeding to colonize it. Despite all these hurdles, however, the results of many studies show that it is possible that panspermia could occur, whether or not it has…at least between planets. The case of interstellar panspermia is trickier, and for the moment, at least, it looks as though that would be almost impossible. The case of the Martian Meteorite ALH84001 has gained a lot of attention lately (and there are many skeptics), but even if it doesn’t actually contain fossilized life, that doesn’t disprove the theory of panspermia. We have concluded that panspermia between planets in a solar system is, in fact possible, though it probably could not occur between solar systems.

Cited References (& Database in which source material was identified)

  1. Arkhipov, AV. 1996. "New Arguments for Panspermia," Observatory 116: 396-7. (Science Citation Index)
  2. Davies, Paul. 1999. The Fifth Miracle, (New York, NY: Simon & Schuster). 221-245. (OBIS)
  3. Hoyle, F & N.C. Wickramasinghe 2000. Astronomical Origins of Life: Steps Toward Panspermia, (Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers). 1-20. (OHIOLINK)
  4. Kerr, Richard. 2001. "Rethinking Water on Mars and the Origin of Life," Science Magazine, April 2001: 39-40. (Mr. Simonson gave this to us)
  5. Klyce, Brig. 2001. "Panspermia Asks New Questions," OSETI III Conference, San Jose, CA. 22 January 2001. www.panspermia.org. Accessed May 7, 2001. (found via www.dogpile.com)
  6. Koike, J. et all. 1992. "Survival Rates of Some Terrestrial Microorganisms Under Simulated Space Conditions," Advanced Space Research 12: 4271. Qtd. In Davies
  7. Melosh, H.J. 1988. "The Rocky Road to Panspermia," Nature 332: 687-88. (General Science Index)
  8. Postgate, John. 1994. The Outer Reaches of Life (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). Qtd. In Davies
  9. Weber, Paul and Mayo Greenberg. 1985. "Can Spores Survive in Interstellar Space?" Nature 316: 403. (found through bibliography of another article)
  10. Wesson, Paul, Jeff Secker, and James Lepock. "Panspermia Revisited: Astrophysical and Biological Constraints," in Cosmovici et al. Eds., Astronomical and Biochemical Origins: 539. Qtd. In Davies
  11. "Life from Outer Space, or Panspermia Redux," Discover, July 1987: 10. (Periodical Abstracts)
  12. "Mars Life or Microscope Artifact?" www.sciencenow.sciencemag.org/sample/1997/1204/1.shtml. 4 December 1997. Accessed May 8, 2001. (www.google.com)

This paper was completed as part of the course requirements for Geo117. All source materials have been acknowledged to the best of our ability. The course was taught by Mr. Bruce Simonson, Professor and Chair, Oberlin College Geology Department, with assistance related to the research process for geological and related information from Ms. Alison Ricker, Science Librarian.

 

<