Pompa-Baldi
Finds the Right Balance at Finney
By
Matthew Heck
Antonio
Pompa-Baldi, former guest faculty member at Oberlin Conservatory,
opened the 124th season of the Artist Recital Series last Thursday.
The 27-year old pianist, winner of the silver medal at the 11th
Van Cliburn International Piano Competition in 2001, brought a lengthy
and eclectic program of works by Mozart, Chopin and the 20th-century
Argentinian composer Alberto Ginastera.
Pompa-Baldi’s performance of Mozart’s "Sonata in
F major K 332" was tasteful and exciting. It seems like the
majority of Mozart interpretations recently have been neither of
these. Performers are either too concerned with being expressive
or too concerned with being authentic or tasteful. The result is
a performance that is either indulgent or boring. Thankfully, Pompa-Baldi
was neither of these things. He played with an extremely light touch
and subtle dynamic control, and his rhythmic poise, tempo and interpretive
decisions were well prepared, logical and musical. The second movement
– "Adagio" – was especially gorgeous.
Pompa-Baldi’s second piece, Chopin’s "Sonata No.
2 in B-flat minor, Op. 35," was equally beautiful but entirely
different. He took more liberties with tempo and expression but
only those that fit the nature of the piece and the period it was
written. The incredibly overplayed third movement – "Funeral
March" – sounded fresh, new and never sensationalized,
and all of the melodies were highlighted and clear. It was almost
as though Pompa-Baldi was both performing and explaining at the
same time: a mark of an inspired performer. Parts of the fourth
movement of the Chopin and the Mozart were a little muddy, probably
due to the vast space of Finney Chapel, but whatever articulation
he lost he made up for in dynamic inflection and phrasing.
Pompa-Baldi returned from the break to perform Chopin’s "Barcarolle,
Op. 60." This piece and the following piece, Grieg’s
“Holberg Suite Op. 40,” originally composed for string
orchestra, were refreshing and relatively light. The lilting rhythms
of the Chopin piece were perfect and the Holberg interpretation
made any performance of the well-known string orchestra version
look like a waste of time.
However, the really interesting part of the second half came after
both of these pieces when Pompa-Baldi performed Alberto Ginastera’s
"Sonata No. 1 in a minor, Op. 22." Ginastera wrote this
sonata in 1952, the first in a series of three. As the program notes
stated, this piece represented a duality of classical form and contemporary
content. The piece shared some connections with the Chopin sonata
earlier in the program, namely a slow third movement and a movement
dominated by fast soft runs. The first and last movements were loud
and exciting, but the rhythms and harmonies occasionally bordered
on cheesy. At times the writing sounded like some new-age jazz with
obvious, annoying syncopations. Pompa-Baldi’s playing was
of course fantastic so if the piece had anything to offer, this
would be the performance to get it. His stylistic and interpretive
decisions shined lights on all sorts of little interesting parts
especially on the more successful second and third movements. The
slow movement was especially nice. The writing was much deeper even
though the movement was structurally quite simple; most of the phrases
outlined chords. The sudden tonalities that emerged from the dissonances
and then disappear again were intriguing.
Anyone interested in classical piano music and inspired by tasteful,
subtle playing should see Antonio Pompa-Baldi perform. In a time
when interpretation is increasingly repetitive and dry, his playing
is guaranteed to bring out ideas never heard before both in repertoire
and ideas.
|